Which action do you think shows worse character?

[publicenemy137]

Here is what the poll is about, which do you think shows worse character, Tony Skinn's punch to the groin of unsuspecting Loren Stokes, or Marcus Vick's stomp on Elvis Dumervil calf when he was on the ground. To you non-US college sports people, this happened last year. Tony Skinn is from George Mason University, a Virginia college, and Marcus Vick is from Virginia Tech, another Virginia college. Read the backgrounds below:

*Background:

Background on Tony Skinn's situation (a basketball game):
After losing to Hofstra once (and mason losing their nationally ranked status), GMU was playing their second game with Hofstra 10 days later, and was going to lose. Tony Skinn, a Senior and his last year of college bball, thought their chances of going to the NCAA tournament was gone, because of Hofstra. Feeling frustration, he clenched his fist, and threw it in Loren's direction, and went straight to Loren Stoke's family jewel's. It wasn't a wind up like I thought in my head, but he clocked it good, and good enough that Stokes was rolling on the floor in pain, and could not play the rest of the game. 5 minutes later you see a painful face with an icepack on his balls. Skinn gets thrown out for the rest of the game by his Coach.

Marcus Vick's background (a football game):
Tech expecting to go to a bcs bowl, went on a good run till late in the season with a disappointing loss to Florida State University, ruinin their chances of national glory in a chance to win a bcs bowl. Tech instead plays Louisville in the Gator Bowl, and managed to take the game. Late in fourth quarter, defensive tackle Elvis Dumervil tackled Marcus Vick. Marcus gets up, frustrated, and while Elvis was on his stomach on the ground, Marcus looks down, and does a hard stomp on the back of his calf. Elvis writhes around in pain. The refs did not catch it, and Vick and Elvis finish the game.

Both sustained short-term injury and nothing long-term. Though maybe Stoke's babies will come out bruised, who knows. Also this isn't about overall person or who got what they deserved, it is just about this action itself, which is worse character. So vote above, to which you think shows worse character.

[publicenemy137]

hmm 40 views and no votes or replies. background too long?

[2.2 Straight six]

if you want opinions based on the actions, without bias then why post examples of certain people? an unbiased opinion will come from you asking which is worse of two acts, without giving examples of people who've done them.

[Moppie]

More importantly, who really cares?

[2.2 Straight six]

Originally Posted by Moppie

More importantly, who really cares?

a very valid point.

who cares and what's this relevant to?

[Damien]

yeah, im from va. idc. i remembered when it happen and well, zidane was a bigger deal than this.

by the way, can you believe what was revealed as what was actually said!?! wow, what a waste of a headbutt! how could he. i think that shows worse character.

*thread hijack*

[Oz]

<----- This Thread.

[93rollaracer]

Alright back on track you fucks...

Anyways, I voted for Vick, but either way, both guys are assholes.

[00accord44]

A) Shouldn't this be in sports forums?

B) This stuff happened forever ago. Skinn was in first round of NCAA Championship last year. Baby Vick was 2 seasons ago.

[publicenemy137]

well it came up b/c i was discussing it with a friend who went to tech. I was just curious what most people would think would show worst character. I think vick cause stepping a guy on teh ground is crass. Hitting someone in the nuts is a lot more painful, true, but I still think it's worse to stomp someone on the calf when they are down, not to mention Vick wasn't frustrated or anything they were winning the Gator bowl.

[Moppie]

I added some extra options to the poll, just to make it a little more interesting.

[00accord44]

Originally Posted by Moppie

I added some extra options to the poll, just to make it a little more interesting.

But who in the world would pick option #4?

[Jimster]

I have a small penis.

[ThatRoundHeadedKid]

I'm sorry jim, that must me tough for you....

[00accord44]

Originally Posted by 00accord44

But who in the world would pick option #4?

When I posted this there was only one person I could think of that might actually do it...

Originally Posted by Jimster

I have a small penis.

I was right