very important question...

[CivicType-R]

if a tree falls in the woods and no one was around to hear it and there was no way of recording it - would it make a sound

How do you know?

or Why doenst it?

and How do you know?

[olds88]

whom gives a shit????:bandit:

[primera man]

Originally posted by CivicType-R
if a tree falls in the woods and no one was around to hear it and there was no way of recording it - would it make a sound

How do you know?

or Why doenst it?

and How do you know?

WTF ..LOL

Go over to your neighbours and cut one down and post back what happens !!!!

[olds88]

its supposed to to be one of deep thought questions. but there is no answer

[igor@af]

I say it doesn't make a sound at all... prove me wrong.:smoker:

[deftonez24]

Ok, time to get all freudian on you. I think that this isnt about trees at all is it son? This is about your parents isnt it? You see, the forest is your parents and you are the tree, and you are asking, how big of a "crash" or rebelious teen life you must lead to make an impact in the "forest" or in this case your parents. The answer is simple. Do not fall, but grow with the forest, learn to live with the forest as it grows along with you. together you, the tree, and the forest, your parents, will live in harmony.

ok sorry i felt like being all philosophical. anyway. i think it depends on the size of the tree, and of course it would make a noise.:smoker2:

[primera man]

WOW .....you know your stuff !!!!

[deftonez24]

Yeah that all came from watching Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure one too many times.

[CivicType-R]

deftonez24 Ok, time to get all freudian on you. I think that this isnt about trees at all is it son? This is about your parents isnt it? You see, the forest is your parents and you are the tree, and you are asking, how big of a "crash" or rebelious teen life you must lead to make an impact in the "forest" or in this case your parents. The answer is simple. Do not fall, but grow with the forest, learn to live with the forest as it grows along with you. together you, the tree, and the forest, your parents, will live in harmony.

ok sorry i felt like being all philosophical. anyway. i think it depends on the size of the tree, and of course it would make a noise.


wow - that was deep but no it really was about the tree not my life - thanks anyhow - i just felt like asking a stupid question that really doesnt have an answer - or at least not one that is proven by facts

[olds88]

well you could put a microphone in the woods but that would wreck the philisophical purpous

[Steel]

Sure there's an answer. If you think of sound, as the vibration of air molecules, then that tree would sure ass hell make a sound. But if you think of sound as the PERCEPTION of those vibrating air molecules, then no, no sound.

[Racing Rice]

Originally posted by igor@af
I say it doesn't make a sound at all... prove me wrong.:smoker:

Well I say it does and prove me wrong.... Say you are deaf and some one is talking to you does that mean that no noise is coming out of the persons mouth... From the deaf person point of view... Yes, thats exactly what it means.. But from someone that can hear then the answer is No, that statement would be wrong... So depending on who you are there is no right or wrong answer to this question..

[igor@af]

uhm.... DUH ...?

[Racing Rice]

That was my thought exactly..

[TheMan5952]

If a man is alone in the woods, and no woman is around to hear him, is he still wrong?

hehe