your opinion pls!

[craz235]

i noticed that it need new gasket, also fluid and filter.

i want your opinion- would you replace tranny filter and fluid yourself

or

take it to a chevrolet place and have them flush it out, i called them they say that they dont replace the filter cuz they use machine to drain and put some cleaner to clean the filter then replace fluid and gasket.

which way would you go if you were me?? just wanna make right choice.

[jakegday]

Originally Posted by craz235

which way would you go if you were me?? just wanna make right choice.

i would just do it myself, but thats just me, im cheap and im a do-it-yourselfer, and besides, a new filter has GOT to be cleaner then a cleaned filter

[craz235]

yea i agree with you... my husband alway says like "save money, save money" lol

tmw i ll have it change and replace the filter and gasket. after that i hope it quit giving me trouble but it happens since that i just traded in my 1989 chev 4x4 in for 1998 chev cavalier.

[Classicrocjunkie]

I did mine myself.... And will again when i swap the built 2200 back into my car this comming year... Just to be sure when i get the Auto trans interceptor as well.

[craz235]

i remmy seeing something about AutoTrans Interceptor on tv one day. arent sure what it does. have fun swapping

[Thor06]

If you are mechanically inclined, have a Haynes manual, and some time, I would definately do it. I have done a couple of them, they arent too bad.

[01Cavy]

Originally Posted by Classicrocjunkie

I did mine myself.... And will again when i swap the built 2200 back into my car this comming year... Just to be sure when i get the Auto trans interceptor as well.

How many miles you got on your new engine?

[Boogieman142]

just do it yourself with a new filter and gasket. I believe that it is better for the tranny just doing it yourself, the tranny flush isn't always good for the tranny.

[jakegday]

Originally Posted by Boogieman142

the tranny flush isn't always good for the tranny.

why?

[craz235]

i am not sure why you shouldnt do tranny flush but i was looking around about it and i saw a website and it say:

NEVER, EVER, DO TRANSMISSION FLUSH, UNLESS YOU HAVE MONEY FOR NEW TRANSMISSION!

for what reason, i dunno but it kinda scare me, lol i m gonna have my hubby do it the old-fashion way.

[cdru]

I'd do it myself. Look at the condition of the ATF when it comes out as well as the filter and magnet stuck to the pan. If you see chunks of anything, a flush may be benificial. If the fluid is still red or reddish brown, a flush won't do anything. A greasy, silver substance around the magnet and in the bottom of the pan is normal. Just clean it out, wash it down with a solvent cleaner, let it dry, then put everything back.

[Boogieman142]

Originally Posted by jakegday

why?

When you do a tranny flush it takes whatever dirt and abrasive material that was sealing up the transmission and making it work properly out and therefore it doesn't work well anymore. Some trannys will let go 200 miles after a flush even. It also shocks the transmission similar to you getting all nice and warm in a jacuzzi and then jumping into a pool. It just can't handle it, just like some engines just can't handle the sudden switch over to synthetic. However, an engine is much more durable than an automatic transmission, the tranny is usually the weak link in the system. By the way about the flush, my builder told me that right after he built my tranny after I did a flush. Some dealers will tell you that it wo't hurt it and can only help it, this is true in theory however automatic transmissions do some funny things. They will also tell you that the flush will on ly bring what problems that are in there out so you will notice them more, this also is not true, that is just how they cover their @$$ for when your tranny lets go. If the problems are in there than you will prolly notice them unless you have an electronic tranny and the computer compensates for pressure drops, which you won't even notice it going until it goes unless you do a scan. I hope this helps a little if you have any other questions just post it in here.

[03cavPA]

The guy who does all the work I don't do myself is probably the best tranny guy in the area. He says there is a lot of information out now that suggests those tranny flushes do more harm than good. There have been instances where the flush actually blows seals out of the tranny. Definitely deadly for the tranny.

All I've ever had done is filter and fluid changes. I see the manual for my 03 says the first filter change should be 100k for normal service, 50k for severe duty. I asked him about it, and he said manuf. are going to extended intervals without any damage to the trans.

[Project_Cav]

Originally Posted by Boogieman142

When you do a tranny flush it takes whatever dirt and abrasive material that was sealing up the transmission and making it work properly out and therefore it doesn't work well anymore. Some trannys will let go 200 miles after a flush even. It also shocks the transmission similar to you getting all nice and warm in a jacuzzi and then jumping into a pool. It just can't handle it, just like some engines just can't handle the sudden switch over to synthetic. However, an engine is much more durable than an automatic transmission, the tranny is usually the weak link in the system. By the way about the flush, my builder told me that right after he built my tranny after I did a flush. Some dealers will tell you that it wo't hurt it and can only help it, this is true in theory however automatic transmissions do some funny things. They will also tell you that the flush will on ly bring what problems that are in there out so you will notice them more, this also is not true, that is just how they cover their @$$ for when your tranny lets go. If the problems are in there than you will prolly notice them unless you have an electronic tranny and the computer compensates for pressure drops, which you won't even notice it going until it goes unless you do a scan. I hope this helps a little if you have any other questions just post it in here.

that doesnt even make sense...if you take away the dirt your reversing a seal on the transmission case ?...what about a car that just came off the factory line and has like .1 kilometes on it ?..if what you saying is true..then new cars shouldnt be working
and why cant an engine switch over from normal to synthetic ? i did it on my car with no problems

[Boogieman142]

Originally Posted by Project_Cav

that doesnt even make sense...if you take away the dirt your reversing a seal on the transmission case ?...what about a car that just came off the factory line and has like .1 kilometes on it ?..if what you saying is true..then new cars shouldnt be working
and why cant an engine switch over from normal to synthetic ? i did it on my car with no problems

Ok, first of all you need to understand what you are reading and actually know something about it. You obviously have no idea what you are talking about. The exact quote from my builder when i asked him what he thought about doing a flush "Don't tamper with a blood clot" He doesn't even do flushes. He is the best around that I know of, he's been building trannys for 45 years, so I think that he knows what he's talking about. No, if what i am saying is true then new cars should work like new. About the switching over to synthetic, I said some engines not all, read before you type. The synthetic is a thinner oil and it hardens seals so they may leak, depending on age and how it has been taken care of. You need to learn how to interpret things, Read the post over again, then figure out what it is saying then post a message when u know what you are talking about.