My friend just sent me this link as a reference for the two tone paint job (still hasn't sent me a pic of the real car):
So, comparing it to the pic of what I had done for the starion, I have masked the dividing line too high on the body. I guess it's different for the Conquest (I was looking for pics of a two tone Starion and not a two tone Conquest). So I guess the damage on the bumper I created doesn't matter anymore since the paint job itself is incorrect. I'll try repaint it so that the dividing line is lower, but if I can't paint it correctly using more masking tape, I'll have to strip the whole thing again and start over...again.