Which would you prefer?

[Boosted1]

The Bimmer's the better car. Gas mileage and repair/maintainance costs would deter me from buying doing the trade though. As well, a B18C1 in a Civic SHOULD be able to compete with the BMW, probably beat it down low...yours I don't know, because it's not working right. Just list your own pros and cons of each, and then make a decision based on YOUR preferences.

[Polygon]

No question, I would take the BMW.

[TypeS]

You shouldn't even think twice about this one, and I think you already know the answer.

[MR2Driver]

The BMW, no question. Even though those have a curb weight of 4,498 lbs.