Broken.
Another Xterra owner sent me a new one, but it doesn't have the winch mounting tip for the start of the line. Not sure what I'm going to do with that. Maybe see if a shop has something to crimp it on.
Interestingly enough. When I took off the broken winch line the end that mounts to the winch wasn't even connected. Looks like it broke a long time ago.
Either that or get a Masterpull.