That 53+ inch width and the dual handles are key. Since it didn't fit the '09 Santa Fe, it's likely for another Hyundai model. Check for any part numbers on the cover itself. In the meantime, quickly compare images of cargo covers for the Hyundai Tucson or ix35 (its European name). Let me know what you find!
Finding the right car accessories can sometimes be as "brain-hacking" as trying to block the last "Draw Four" card in Uno! Hope you find the right cargo cover soon. If you have time, play a few rounds of Uno Online Free to entertain yourself after these "brain-hacking" hours.
__