View Single Post
Old 12-20-2017, 01:51 AM   #4
brcidd
AF Enthusiast
 
brcidd's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: troy, Ohio
Posts: 2,313
Thanks: 2
Thanked 173 Times in 171 Posts
Re: 97 Lumina Intermittently Won't Crank With New Starter

To be absolutely certain- next time you are in "no-start" condition- have assistant hold key in start position- and you tap on starter- if it starts- then definitely the starter is bad- armature is not centered properly in brushes- just like a worn out starter where bushings allow armature to go off center. It actually may "wear-in" and get better- but that is a crap-shoot- depends on your luck--

If it were mine, (I have remote starts installed) I can tap on it by myself- but everyone looks at me funny in the parking lots while I do it--

I'd take starter back and get a new one- never rebuilt....
__________________
Automotive A/C Engineer with:
'99 IH 4700 Toy Hauler
(2) '95 GEO Prizms both maroon
'99 GMC Yukon
'95 Chev 3500, 454 Dually Crew Cab- 145k miles-
Wife's Camel trailer puller.
'94 Astro- 370k miles
'94 Firebird Formula- 5.7L 180k miles- gone-
'92 Chevy Lumina Van 3.8L 264k
'86 GMC S-15 - 2.8L 154k
'87 Buick Park Ave . 187k
'86 Buick Park Ave 3.8L 199k miles- gone
'77 Chevy Vega- 2.5L 175k miles gone but not forgotten
'68 Camaro 396 4 spd RS/SS -72k miles-
brcidd is offline   Reply With Quote