[wayaboveme]

Well, guess I figured it out myself. Didn't have to take the wheel off. Just unscrewed the two torx screws on the bottom piece and it falls off. Then I cracked the top off to realize that there is one screw holding it in on the right underside closest to the driver. Getting the new pieces back in took a bit but finally they snapped together. Success!

Now, anyone know why I might be having a water leak under my front driver's side mat? I noticed the moisture while working there!