[MikeO89]

I'll answer my own question. Turns out it was the motor. First I ordered just the motor but after trying to get the other one out I saw there was no way that I could see to replace one of the needed bolts to put on the new motor. I then called back (Oreillys) and ordered the whole motor regulator assembly. No nuts or bolts are included so I bought 4 1/4 x 20 x 1/2 bolts and nyloc nuts. Watched a youtube vid on it (those vids have saved my butt more than a few times) and went to work. Drilled out the old rivets (instead on punching chiseling out like the vid) cause I didn't want to beat on the door. Got it out and put the new one in with just a bit of fiddling and help from my son holding the window. For clearance reasons I ended up inserting the top two bolts with nuts on the back and the bottom two with nuts on the front. Worked out perfect. First time doing something like this. Well now I know how if any of the others decide to quit working.