Seeing as how I'm really favored towards Chevy (always have proven to hold up and perform better than Fords- just observations from different friends' experiences) I would go with the Camaro. and I think the new Camaro is much nicer looking than the new Mustang. I would consider looking into the 2010s, they're only a yr old so wont have much use on them, but you wont have to deal with the instant depreciation of buying brand new.