Ive gotta go with the VW...the looks are good for a hatchback as in the Mini but it doesnt look as tiny. The Mini just looks to small for most people. Everyone I've seen driving one looks like they are in a clown car. But thats just my opinion. The Civic is definatly a peice of crap and the focus is a big step up for American cars. Also the VW for its quality level. Great fit and finish inside and out. Thats what counts to the "ladies" it feels higher end than the other cars. If not for the Mini being so small and kinda girly that would be the winner for me.