It's something different every weekend...
My motor "clicks" when you press the button and I'm getting voltage, so it may very well be the motor. I found this item, combination motor/regulator by Dorman for only $50 through Amazon.
Is this the way to go? How difficult is it to install this thing in the door, doesn't look like it will fit through anywhere.
Dorman 741-870
http://www.amazon.com/Dorman-Solutio.../dp/B000TYTSG4