Ahh, but there's a twist! [dramatic music]
Let's compare a 2002 S2000 w/ hardtop with a 1991 NSX with 60K miles on it. This is purely hypothetical, so feel free to discuss the merits/downfalls of a ten-year-old sports car. Also, to keep this simple, let's say the NSX is unmodified, was always garaged, and has been well-maintained.
Me: I'd take the NSX almost without thinking. It's a freaking
NSX!!!