The points for the mud bog were not the only points...the ranking was based upon several other tests, such as a hill climb, etc....and the BFG lost points...So the GY MT/R beat it in the Mud, and on trails and rocks too.
(There was No math mistake! BFG LOST to GY, and ended up mid-pack)
Also - The three BFG sidewalls are less tough than the MT/R's side walls, and the TSL's too. (The outer BFG layer is practically cosmetic anyway if you cross section it....which I have)
I have run BFG's MT and AT's. I have not seen the new MT version on a trail yet...I hear it looks more butch, but works about the same. The MT/R's do clean out mud well, Better than the BFG MT. This is supported by the Mud Pit results above actually, as well as my own observations.
Food for thought.
If they were all free, this would be an easier choice...Boggers.
- Lance