I think your critique was a bit harsh Oli. I think if that comment was posted about my work, I'd be a little upset. However, I do like your honesty.
I have strayed from AF and don't post much here anymore because I tired of seeing poor work receiving comments like "awesome" and "great work". Dont get me wrong though, there are still truly inspiring builds being posted here.
Getting constructive criticizm and tips helped me become a better modeler. If everyone had said "awesome" when it really wasn't, I would not have improved.
While I'm all for honesty and constructive criticism, it can be worded as not to offend.