I'm surprised that they recommended that size tire. Most places will recommend 235/60 -16. Before you buy the tires, go to a good tire shop and talk to them about changing sizes. Also there is a website:
www.1010tires.com (click on "tire size calculator" on the left) that allows you to compare alternate size tires. It will alert you if you are outside the recommended parameters. Put in the OEM size and under alternate sizes use: 235/60 and 215/65. I think the 235/60 is closer to the OEM specs and there are tons of choices including tires from Toyo.