[JLad10687]

Im assuming the are both auto becasue I dont think they made either with a manual tranny, correct me if I'm wrong.

The power is probably about equal in both, the Monte Carlo may have a quicker 0-60 but the Grand Am might be better for passing.

Exterior looks goes to the Grand am just because I never saw a Monte Carlo that I thought was nice looking. However, the alloys are nicer then the plastic.

Interior looks probably goes to the Grand Am just becasue of the leather. The Monte Carlo is probably a little bigger but Chevys interiors are very cheap(well in fact, most GM interiors are but especially Chevy). And I think leather looks like a million bucks.

Reliablitly is a push.

Id rather drive the Grand Am, but thats becasue I hate Monte Carlos to begin with.