[Zachp911]

Originally Posted by SuperHighOutput

Unless he's dead set on an RX-8, the others are better cars, and personally I love the RX-8, but the rotary tends to use a lot of oil, gets rather poor gas milage considering it's output, and reliability is questionable. The S2000 is a great car, but lacks torque and low-end power, however I understand it handles very well and it's a Honda. The G35 is a great car, as well as the 350Z, but the G35 just seems to be a step up from the 350Z in terms of luxury and overall quality, but you pay for it. The Yukon XL is a good vehicle, but I don't see why an 18 year old would need a Suburban. The GTO is awesome, and is quite fast, but insurance will be very high. The interior is very nice one of GM's best, and overall quality is very good. All of them will be safe, pretty much every new car on the road is safe these days. Out of the choices I'd go with GTO. It screams badass, which is perfect for an 18 year old, as long as he can control his right foot. You might also look at a Lexus IS300, BMW 3-series, and Acura TSX.

On a side note I wouldn't trust Consumer Reports reliability ratings, many people myself included feel that they are biased against American cars and biased for certain brands, and I'm a multiple time and current owner of a Japanese vehicle.

My choice would be the G35 Coupe. Luxurious yet sporty, has plenty of power for an 18 year old, good quality car, and last... the car is just plain sexy.