[kmohr3]

Maybe I'm on the wrong track here, but is it possible a piece of the broken starter is hung up in the flywheel/bell housing/torque converter area causing the engine not to turn? Can you turn the engine either way?

Also, I'm pretty sure the 3.8 liter is not an interference engine, so even if it jumped time you should still be able to physically turn the motor.

BTW, do you know what made the starter break?