Now that i've played around with it a little more, i've discovered some more details about the problem (still havent gotten around to calling a family member who is a mechanic). I noticed that it stops when the car is all warmed up from moving, not just warming up idle... but moving.
I found this out by warming up my car in park for about 15 minutes, then reving the engine in park, the clicking noise disappeared for a while after that. Now that I have anti-freeze/coolant back in my car the clicking noise stays longer because obviously the engine wont heat up as fast. Pretty much now it stops after 10 minutes of driving, but still doesn't sound healthy at all. More thoughts on the possible problem would be helpful.