WIP Truck... Yes Or No?

i dont know about you guys but i personally think that there should be a
WIP Truck category.. i think we should have this because i love to build truck models and i dont think that they trchnically fall into any of the WIP categories that we already have. plus it would make it alot easier to keep an eye on the progress... let me know what you all think.

No- Trucks fit easily into the currently existing categories. Is it a racing truck? It goes into motorsports. Is it a muscletruck? it goes into musclecars. Is it something else? It goes into street/show.

Trucks are not unique enough (nor are their enough built here) to justify tampering with the hierarchy here.

I say yes because it's hard to find truck WIP's and
the street section is too crowded, mine's way back
a few pages already. Plus trucks are cool.

I would also say yes: I think they are a varied enough topic that they could use their own section: 4x4s, big rigs, street trucks, racing trucks, show trucks, low-riders, etc.

Personally don't see the need. There are so few built here and they can already be categorized easily.

I say yes.

Yes.

I was thinking about another sub-forum that includes trucks, suvs, AT-vehicles, movie vehicles....that sort. Maybe could be called 'non-mainstream models'.
These types of models are not as popular and are extremely hard to find in the current sub-forums.

:2cents:
Steve

No- Trucks fit easily into the currently existing categories. Is it a racing truck? It goes into motorsports. Is it a muscletruck? it goes into musclecars. Is it something else? It goes into street/show.

Trucks are not unique enough (nor are their enough built here) to justify tampering with the hierarchy here.

I agree.

i'd like to see a truck sub-forum. it would be a good place to divide trucks (as in pick-ups) and commercial vehicles from the other sub-forums.

I say yes.

Well of course erb says yes.:rolleyes:

I would agree on a truck section on PRINCIPLE, but as was pointed out, very few trucks are ever built here anyway.

Maybe If there was a place for them you would see more on here. I say yes. What "hierarchy" are you guys talking about???? It would be another couple of buttons to click on, whats the big deal?? If you don't want to click on them then don't, but don't discriminate just because you don't and you don't know of anyone else that builds trucks.

Icon Modeler

There are too many sub forums as it is so personally I don't think so. Just my opinion.

Maybe If there was a place for them you would see more on here. I say yes. What "hierarchy" are you guys talking about???? It would be another couple of buttons to click on, whats the big deal?? If you don't want to click on them then don't, but don't discriminate just because you don't and you don't know of anyone else that builds trucks.

Icon Modeler This is exactly why I hate sub forum (and discussion of it), because it crates unnecessary tension between modelers with different interests.

Icon Modeler, no one says that truck modelers can be discriminated. No one should be discriminated, and no one disagrees with that. But the flip side of it is that no one should be privileged either, don't you think so?

You might not know, but AF used to be a giant community without any sub-forums. Think of it as New York, a big melting pot of all kinds of people. It didn't matter what subject you liked, or how good of a modeler you were. The diversity created an welcoming atmosphere, which resulted in the fastest growing online modeling community.

Then WIP sub forum was created because the majority of people agreed with such split, and the board became more organized than before.

The next was Motorsports, which I openly criticized it for shortsightedness (and many other reasons, even though I'm an avid race car modeler), but anyway the split was done. After that, it was just a matter of time--creation of Muscle/Hot Rod and Motorbikes sub forums--and now we're discussing Trucks.

In my opinion, each individual is unique, and each has a favorite subject or two, but living in a part of community (whether online or off line) means that we all have to compromise. While I see the pain of the truck modelers, it can be reduced by using subscription and search functions, as well as web-browsers' ctrl+f and bookmarks.

Whether it's easy or difficult to navigate is an individual level of problem, not organizational. Usually, you don't apply an organizational solution like creating a sub forum to solve such problem.

Having said that, separating cars and trucks make more sense than separating muscle cars from other cars, so if the majority wants a truck forum, I guess that's the way it should be (though I still don't like the idea.) If not, well...I'm sorry, but the truck modelers have to put up with some inconvenience, but keep in mind that it's not because truck modelers are discriminated. Everyone (except for the motorsports, muscle/hot rods and moborbike modelers) are compromising.

Every time a new sub forum is added, I see the AF loosing its openness, diversity and uniqueness, looking like the more organized Scale Auto. That continues bothering me...

Trucks are no excpetion to the works in progress thread, it doesnt say " car works in progress".

i say "yes" do to i build trucks and i would like to have a place for them ,but i do agree with the "no's" as well do to there aint many trucks built probably cause of there is no truck forums!

Due to! Oh!

I agree with Hiro on this one. I don't care for race cars or bikes all that much, so I don't go into the those forums, but look at all the detailed builds I miss because of it. but I DO see the use in having a truck forum. maybe labeling it as a comercial/truck/heavy equipment forum. I have several friends that never came to A/F due to the fact that it was all imports and sports. they build hotrods, and race cars. now that there are supporting forums, they are on here all the time, though I don't think they ever post. they love it though.

I think it'd be great if we could get some of the big rig modelers on here, I LOVE seeing their builds, and the extent of some of their details on their trucks.

in short, a truck/comercial vehicle/heavy equipment forum would be justified.

however, most PICKUP trucks can be categorized by any of the existing forums. race, hotrod, street. but then there are comercial CARS. I see lots of cars around town with logos on their doors and equipment in their backseats, and trunks. would those still be labeled as street?

really I guess each individual is resposible for putting their builds in the appropriate forum, and if it's obviously mistakenly placed in the wrong forum, then move it, and leave the ghost in the forum so people can see that it was moved.

:banghead: Come on guys!!

Of course a Commercial/Truck forum is "justified" just in the way that the Muscle, Bike, Street and MS sub-forums are.

The relevant question still remains IMO the same though - "What the heck for???"

Please someone, apply Occam's Razor before we go ape with Drifter, Dub and Municipal Vechicle forums!!

Well, I say yes. And would be happy to post my first WIP there, since I'm now working on the Italeri Mercedes-Benz Actros Megaspace. And I also have other trucks in the "to do" pile.

i agree with hiro,i don't like sub-forums either.