Window switch trim question....

i couldn't find anything searching, but my d/s window switch panel has the tab at the top broken....apparently just like every 4door GP out there...so common that the local dealership keeps them in stock,and they're only 13 bucks...that was cool anyway (i had some dealer vouchers i needed to use)...

my question is this, when i took off the old trim panel (with switches still attached) and went to transfer the swithces to the new piece, i noticed my stock one was black, and the new was just a dark grey...i went ahead and installed it, and it matches the grey of the door panel almost perfectly, but the pass side window switch panel is black as well, but the backs are the same grey...is this right?? are there two diffent interiors to where the replacement piece would be a different color? i think i may try to paint the pass side one to match, then they'll all be grey...

The replacement bezel is only available in grey (graphite), just for reference.