AFI, cd choices- help!

I just bought Sing the Sorrow ( I think thats what its called) the other day, and it is the best CD I have bought in a very long time. My question is, whoch of their other cd's sounds most like the one Ive got?

Black Sails In The Sunset is my favourite album from them.

don't know about it sounding like Sing the Sorrows though.

Beat me to it, Black Sails In the Sunset is probably their best cd they released.