B&M short shifter question

i'm lookin to buy a short shifter for my car and i heard b&m make a very good product but theres 2 to chose from theres product number 45074 and product number 45075 from www.bmracing.com the main question is will the shifter size on both be shortened and the throw.

B&M shifters are too short IMO. The length & throw are reduced. I wish my Hurst was a little bit longer, nothing worse than reaching for the shifter.

which shifter do you think is the perfect length?

I have not seen any aftermarket shifters that I would consider a perfect lenght - custom made would be the best way to go.

you tried DC sports? they make decent ones

i just got my clutch and light weight flywheel in the mail, so i was thinking that a short shifter would finish off the whole package.

which would you suggest, and which should i shy away from?