budget vs. cattman y-pipe

which one is better for a 4th gen max budget or cattman.... cattman is 1 bill more than budget.... performance wise which is better for the dollar...

i'm not sure what cattman's numbers are for a 4th gen but this is the HP curve for a 95 5 speed with a stillen cone filter vs the same car with the budget y pipe added: http://www.motorvate.ca/auto/maxima/ypipe/images/ypipe_comp_ro_hp.jpg
and this is the torque:
http://www.motorvate.ca/auto/maxima/ypipe/images/ypipe_comp_ro_torq.jpg

you can see 18 hp gains and as much as 30+ ins the 6k-6600rpm range and 19 lbs of Tq. avg increases. and these numbers are taken at the wheels so that really is a substantial gain. compared to any other mod the y pipe is the best.
this is an article that talks about this mod.
http://www.motorvate.ca/mvp.php/504

cattman's good too though. i'm gettin a mid pipe and y pipe from them once my cash flow picks up a bit.