2004 M3 vs. 530i

Hello all,

I'm trying to make what seems to be a very difficult decision between purchasing a 2004 M3 or a 2004 530i. Seeing as how the M3 is obviously an extreme sports car yet offers comfort and luxury where as the 530i is the a solid choice when it comes to pure luxury with some sportiness, I'd like to ask all of you who might know, how does the M3 compare to the 530i in every day driving? Is the M3 so sporty that you start regretting it for everyday city driving?

It's important to note that I would get the M3 with the SMG option so I'm making this comparison based on both cars being automatic as opposed to using the clutch.

Lastly, I am concerned about repairs. Specifically, a car such as the M3 means extreme performance and as such, I question the reliability down the road of the engine, transmission, suspension as well as all the other parts of a car that at some point fail and need to be repaired/replaced. Comparing the M3's reliability to that of the the 530i, I'd like to get your opinions as to whether or not there's even cause to make this comparison. In other words, are both cars based upon your experience excellent when it comes to repairs? Money aside, it's obviously expensive for repairs when owning either of these 2 cars (after the warranty is up) but what do you all think?

Thanks very much!

If you have that kind of money "M3"; my advise would be to look into the 540i. It's a V8, 325hp, loaded w/every option that you could think of and will also be a family car when you want it to be. No matter which BMW you purchase the cost to repair will hurt. Hope this helps.