Help! Which one?!?!??!

OK. I'm 17 and ready to buy first a car. I have about $9500+ saved up. Ive been going crazy about choosing a car.....Some of my favorites:
- 04-05 Chrysler Crossfire
- 03-05 Audi A4
- 03-05 Scion Tc
- 01-02 Audi TT
- 01-03 BMW 3 Series
- 04-05 Mazda RX-8
- 00-02 BMW Z3
- 03-04 Acura RSX
- 05-06 Mazda 6
- 03-04 Nissan Altima
- 03-04 Ford Mustang
- 04-05 Mazda 3

I am looking for a sporty looking car that is reliable, Fast, low maintenance/part cost, fairly low insurance, and Looks good Inside and Out!

Can someone help me pick out the Best bang for the buck...Please Put lists from Best to Worst in terms of reliability, Speed, maintenance/part cost, insurance Cost, and Looks.

Thanks a lot!!! I really appreciate this..Thanks