Need Advice About Selling Car (PLEASE READ)

[Yerbison]

Hello,

I needed some advice about selling my 2010 KIA Rio LX on Craigslist, This is my first time selling pretty much anything online.
So far I've; cleaned it myself, but I have a detail service coming to clean it either Monday or Tuesday as well as an oil change.
The car has been service routinely and there is absolutely nothing wrong with the engine, This was honestly my first car and it has been so reliable!
It right now has about 58,000 miles on it. It has a Satellite Radio, Aux Input, CD Player, Perfect A/C, Everything works great!

There are however some cosmetic damages....
The carpets and seats are kinda dirty but I'm hoping that will be fixed with the detailing service.
The front fender and back bumper are both missing but it doesn't look that bad....there is a little streak of yellow pant on the side,
and the right head light has a crack in it. Altogether the damages will cost about 1,000 to fix I would estimate.

Now I originally paid 14,000 for it with Tax, Title and Registration from Carmax. I know I'm not going to get that much for it. I shouldn't have paid that much for it LOL.
According to Kelly Blue Book, My car in the VERY WORST CONDITION is worth $7,900. I was thinking of listing it for $5,000 OBO, the lost I would go is probably $4,500

Do you guys think I'm setting my price to low or what? I would really appreciate some feedback