Does the Consult III or service manual indicate if there are any initial conditions that need to be satisfied before programming, such as all doors closed, hood open, etc.?
Not that it matters now, but why did you clear all the fobs before programming new? Usually you can add additional fobs without clearing the original ones. I don't know if that might be part of the issue.
I've done this process on Fords, Mercedes, and Chrysler, but never had to do it on my former G35 so I'm not familiar with the specifics.
-Rod