I dont own an Enclave but do own a Lesabre approaching it's 11th birthday. The motor runs like it's new. No shaking or tapping like the jap cars do.
Buicks are known for their long life expectancy which is why there are millions of old ones like mine still on the road. As old as it is no Jap car can come close to the comfort of a Buick. My sister bought a Toyota Rav4 last year and she took us for a ride in it. The seats were rock hard and the comfort was similar to a park bench
Right now GM is having an "Employee discount sale" You can get the Enclave for at least $3,000 less than the normal price.
My suggestion i to sit down and make a list of what exactly you are looking for in your new vehicle , then take both out for a test drive and evaluate them.
Good luck!
