Our Community is 940,000 Strong. Join Us.


hesitation or hiccup while driving


gutterjrn
07-29-2010, 07:04 PM
I have a 99 grand prix gt with 140K miles. when driving there is an occasional hiccup when driving and sometimes even when braking or stopped. It isnt very consistant. When this happens the tach drops 500 rpms or so but the car doesn die. Any ideas on what the likely culprit is? This has been happening for a few days.

My first thought is to change the fuel filter as it hasnt been changed for a few years, other than that I dont have any ideas on where to begin.

Last time any work of any significance was done was at 95K and the things replaced where fuel filter, PCM, fuel injectors, spark plugs, plug wires, .... and so on (the dealership didnt know what the problem was so they started replacing stuff and the true problem ended up being the PCM)

richtazz
07-30-2010, 08:22 AM
I would change the fuel filter because it's overdue, but I don't think it's causing your issue. does the ABS/Trac-off lights come on when this happens? If so, then I would suspect a bad crank position sensor. Even if it doesn't, the CKPS is the first thing I would look into.

gutterjrn
07-30-2010, 08:34 AM
Thanks....NO lights come on when this happens. I also had the codes checked to see if any existed, there were NO error codes.

richtazz
07-30-2010, 08:59 AM
regretfully, the CKPS will not always trip a code when they start to fail. It usually has to get to a point where the car completely stalls before a CKPS code will trip.

tblake
07-30-2010, 09:17 AM
Rich, and even then it sometimes wont trip a code (the case with my car).

I wonder if this could be a MAF issues. To the OP, try unplugging the MAF sensor and driving the car like that for a day or two to see if the hesitation goes away.

gutterjrn
08-01-2010, 09:13 AM
Is the MAF plug the one on the flex hose just after the air filter? Thanks.

tblake
08-01-2010, 09:31 AM
http://www.automotiveforums.com/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=746374

Unplug the maf with the car off, and start it. Once it idles down take it for a drive and see if the hesitation is gone. With the MAF unplugged, there will be an SES light, and you might lose a mile or so per gallon, but its ok to drive it like this for a while. I drove mine with my MAF unplugged for a week while I waited for a replacement to arrive.

tblake
08-01-2010, 09:32 AM
BTW, when was the last full tune up done on this car?

gutterjrn
08-01-2010, 09:47 AM
My last tune up was around 100K, 40K miles ago.

tblake
08-01-2010, 10:54 AM
was that when you first started noticing the issue? What brand plugs and wires did you go with?

gutterjrn
08-01-2010, 11:17 AM
No, this issue just started. I dont know what brand of plugs the dealership used.

I decided to take it for a little drive today before I unpluged the sensor. I noticed that it only starts to do this once it gets completely warmed up. Tomorrow I am going to unplug the sensor and drive it to work that way to see if anything changes.

c3d6c4c5d9
08-01-2010, 08:54 PM
The CKPS is definately a common failure on GP's, I have replaced the one on my 99 GTP at least twice in 90k miles. I have also experienced the fishbite/hiccup/random struggle with my car. In all the GP forums out there, they pretty much all recommend the CKPS, and then usually the fuel filter and eventually the MAF all within good reason. Unfortunately there are posts where an owner will get to the point where they've replaced all of the listed parts with no solution. . .
Bare with me - just recently I finished a top swap on my car and couldn't get it to start and because I had fuel and compression, but no spark I immediately started t/s near the icm. Only because of chance I was loosening the icm harness when I decided to try and start it again that I got spark. What I found is that if I tightened the icm retaining bolt too much I would kill the engine, and I witnessed the engine begin to struggle as I slowly tightened the bolt. After leaving it in a good spot and being curious - for fun I pushed on either side of the harness and found all the same symptoms. After taking the harness off and inspecting under the rubber grommets I noticed the plastic casing was cracked around the center bolt area. Somehow (engine vibrations + heat causing expansion) the signals were getting shorted to ground via that bolt.
To make a long story short I was able to replicate the random engine struggle and even recreate a bad CKPS symptom (engine stall, tach falls to zero, tcs light) only because that signal goes right through the harness. So do yourself a favor and before replacing other parts that may or may not also need replacement; with the engine running BE CAREFUL DO AT YOUR OWN RISK THERE IS MOVING PARTS CLOSE TO THIS AREA push on either side of the icm harness and see what your engine does. If you have a good harness (that has never been over tightened) your engine should stay running and your problem is caused else where, otherwise you may need to get a new icm harness. I would suggest Morad Parts Company as the dealership will want quite a bit more money for a new one.

gutterjrn
08-02-2010, 05:36 PM
When driving with the MAF unplugged I didnt get any hesitation while driving, only the idle was a little erratic which is to be expected correct? I am going to continue driving a couple more days before ordering the MAF just to be sure.

Where would be the best place to buy a new MAF, what are the thoughts on buying a new one from GM parts direct ($180). Any other suggestions? Thanks.

gutterjrn
08-03-2010, 06:43 AM
Or is it worth it to buy some MAF cleaner and try to clean it first, as far as I know its never been cleaned.

richtazz
08-03-2010, 07:25 AM
The MAF was a god call Tim, not sure why I didn't suggest it, must be CRS kicking in...:lol:. Gutterjrn, you can try to clean it, but regretfully in my experience cleaning rarely works.

tblake
08-03-2010, 07:41 PM
I see zzp is offering GM MAF sensors again for right around 150.00 if I remember right.

Firstymer
08-04-2010, 11:01 AM
Where can I buy a MAF sensor at a reasonable price? I notice sometimes my 00' GP se v6 continue to rough idle at stop lights or sudden stops after speeding; and occasionally hesitation while driving.

tblake
08-04-2010, 11:30 AM
3100 and 3800 MAFS are differed design. Mr. Firstimer, check out www.rockauto.com. The MAF is a rather expensive part to just replace without diagnosis. You could also try disconnecting it to see if your problem changes. I have also done the screwdriver test at idle. Smack the MAF with the handle of a scredriver and if the idle changes the MAF is bad.

gutterjrn
08-06-2010, 12:14 PM
Cleaning the MAF did not work. I may try a junk yard first to see if I can find a MAF from a 99 GT, otherwise I will order one from zzp.

Also I have a long trip to make this weekend so this will be a great test to see if it truely is a MAF problem as to this point all my test drives have been limited to 5 miles.

olopezm
08-06-2010, 08:48 PM
Maybe some people don't like it but try a reman MAF from autozone, I got one from there not long ago and it was cheaper than anywhere else (about $130 dlls with the currency exchange from pesos to dollars), they will take the old one in exchange. Mine has been working fine, unfortunately the car is sitting in my garage because I haven't had spare time to buy and replace the left side trailing arm :(.

richtazz
08-09-2010, 11:47 AM
My car just recently started doing the same thing. Hesitation at shift points, lurching/surging/stalling at stops, etc... and only after the car was warmed up. I was fearing it was trans issues due to the lurching when sitting at a stoplight. No CEL, no codes (pending or otherwise). I decided to hook up my scan tool and have the wife drive while I monitored the scanner data. Every time the car acted up, the MAF signal dropped. Replacing the MAF fixed my issues. I would suggest against a salvage yard MAF, as these are a high failure part. Also, the reman units (even the Ac-Delco reman ones) are questionable at best. I have seen as high as a 50% failure rate, so I believe you got lucky olopezm. If you're going to keep the car, buy a new Delphi/Ac-Delco sensor and be done with it.

gutterjrn
08-13-2010, 09:54 AM
The $50 risk is working out thus far, the junk yard MAF is working correctly but who knows for how long. I really didnt want to spend 150+ for a new one.

tblake
08-14-2010, 12:33 AM
50.00 for a junkyard one? Where at? All the places around me want approx 80.00 for a used one. Mine just went out yesterday again. Car would not accellerate, and then died. Would not restart. Pulled the plug on the MAF and it started right back up.

Its unplugged right now until I can figure something out.

I'm torn. Cause if these Reman/ZZP MAF's only last 2 years topps, and a dealer one is over $300.00. I found a local junkyard that has a used MAF off an 04 bonne with 59,000 miles that was in a front end collision. They want 100.00 for it, spendy for used, but they give a lifetime replacement warrenty so if I ever have an issue again with it, all I have to do is bring it back with my reciept and they will hand me a replacement (used) one no questions asked.

Otherwise I thought about trying to run a 3100/3400 MAF. They seem to have a lower failure rate, and don't appear to block airflow as badly as the 3800 one does. Only issue is I'd need to buy one and spend some serious time tuning the MAF tables with my powertuner.

gutterjrn
08-14-2010, 06:57 AM
I got mine at LKQ, they initially wanted 65 for it and I talked them into 50. It was out of a 01 monte carlo with 60k. Another junkyard I tried wanted 100 which I too thought was crazy. LKQ told me if it didnt work I could bring it back for credit, thus I figured if it didnt work I would just try another one.

Add your comment to this topic!